I spent years drinking more sugar than I realized, mostly through soda and coffee. Cutting it back was not dramatic or miserable once I figured out the right approach. I drink mostly water, coffee, tea, and homemade lemonade now, and I genuinely do not miss the soda. This post covers what changed my thinking, how I drink more water without dreading it, and two simple homemade drink recipes at the bottom that cost almost nothing to make.
Over the years I read a lot of research on sugary drinks and weight gain. One study found that calories from drinks do not trigger the same satiety signals as calories from food. If you drink a 200 calorie beverage, your body largely does not compensate by making you less hungry. You just consume those calories on top of everything else.
Another study split participants into two groups. One group received an extra 450 calories a day from jelly beans, the other from soda, then they were swapped. The group eating jelly beans consumed about 100 fewer calories overall because their bodies partially compensated for the solid food. The soda group showed almost no compensation. The drink calories simply added on top.
And that is before you get to the ingredient that replaced sugar in most American soft drinks starting in the 1980s.
▼ Jump to Iced Tea Recipe ▼ Jump to Lemonade RecipeSeveral studies have found links between high fructose corn syrup (HFCS) and obesity as well as other metabolic problems. HFCS replaced sugar in most soft drinks sold in the US and is now in an enormous number of processed foods. Whether it is uniquely worse than regular sugar is still debated, but the research gives me enough reason to avoid it where I can.
Diet drinks do not seem to be a clean escape either. Some research suggests they can trigger similar insulin responses and cravings as regular sweetened drinks, which undermines the point of switching. I have never been a fan of artificial sweeteners anyway, they taste off to me and I have concerns about long-term effects that are not fully settled yet.
The practical conclusion I landed on was straightforward: make my own drinks so I control what goes into them, and make the healthier options convenient enough that reaching for them becomes the default.
How I Started Drinking More Water
As a kid I did not like water at all. All I wanted was cola. Learning as an adult that there are up to 5 teaspoons of sugar in 8 oz of soda was genuinely alarming in retrospect. It explains a lot about why I was always a little soft around the middle despite not being overweight.
The thing that actually got me drinking more water was a combination of two factors: it needed to be filtered, and it needed to be cold. Tap water in most places has a flavor I find unpleasant, and warm water is hard to drink in volume. Once I addressed both of those, water became significantly easier to reach for.
I use a Brita pitcher to keep filtered water cold in the fridge. The filters last a while and the per-glass cost is a fraction of bottled water. At my desk I use an insulated desk water bottle so I can sip constantly without refilling every 20 minutes. Cold water that stays cold is a simple thing but it genuinely changes how much you drink throughout the day.
When I am out hiking or running I bring a Polar Insulated Water Bottle, and for longer rides or hikes I use a CamelBak hydration pack. Being able to sip continuously without stopping makes it much easier to stay on top of hydration during longer efforts. I sometimes bring both on really hot days, which says something about how much my relationship with water has changed since the Pepsi-only era.
At meals I always have water on the table. If I am thirsty and want something more flavorful, I drink a full glass of water first and then have a smaller amount of whatever else I wanted. It is a simple trick but it reduces the total volume of sugary drinks without feeling like deprivation.
How I Cut Sugar From Coffee
I have one, sometimes two, 10 oz mugs of coffee per day. It does not feel like the day has started without the first one, which I realize is exactly what caffeine dependance sounds like and I have made my peace with it.
I used to put 2 teaspoons of sugar in each mug along with a little low-fat milk. Compared to soda it does not sound like much, but any empty calories I could remove from my daily routine without suffering for it were worth cutting. I dropped to 1 teaspoon and found it noticeably worse for a week or two before I started adjusting.
Rather than forcing myself to accept worse-tasting coffee, I decided to fix the coffee instead. I spent some time learning how to make better tasting coffee at home and realized the automatic drip machine most people use, including me at the time, does a genuinely poor job. The water temperature is too low, the contact time is wrong, and the result is coffee that is either weak and flavorless or bitter and harsh. Adding sugar was a way of compensating for bad coffee.
I switched to a Clever Coffee Dripper, which is an immersion brewer that produces a much cleaner, fuller-flavored cup than a standard drip machine without the bitterness. I also started buying whole beans and grinding them fresh before brewing. The resulting coffee is strong and flavorful enough that I rarely need more than half a teaspoon of sugar now, and sometimes none at all.
If you find yourself putting a lot of sugar in your coffee, it is worth asking whether you are compensating for bad coffee rather than genuinely preferring it sweet. The answer might save you both calories and money on equipment you do not need.
Homemade Alternatives to Soda
Replacing soda with something you actually want to drink is the only strategy that works long term. Willpower alone is not a sustainable plan when you are thirsty and there is a cold Pepsi in the fridge. The key for me was keeping two quart pitchers of homemade drinks ready in the fridge at all times so the convenient option was always something I had made myself.
My main homemade drinks are iced tea, lemonade, and occasionally my homemade orange matcha sports drink when I have a long outdoor workout coming up. For more variety you can buy unsweetened drink mix packets and control exactly how much sugar goes in. The point is that making your own puts you in charge of the sweetener amount rather than whatever the manufacturer decided tastes good to the widest possible audience.
Going out to restaurants is the harder part. When I want something other than water I look for unsweetened iced tea, which most places have. If they do not, I stick with water during the meal and save the flavorful drink for when I get home where I know what is in it.
The two recipes below are what I make most often. Both are cheap, simple, and easy to batch-make for the week.
Simple, lightly sweetened iced tea with a pinch of baking soda to cut bitterness. Makes a 2 quart batch for about 45 cents including tea bags, sugar, and lemon.
Ingredients
- 6 tea bags (black tea)
- 1/4 cup sugar, or however much you like
- Juice of 1/2 a lemon
- 1/8 teaspoon baking soda
- 8 cups cold filtered water, divided
Directions
- Bring 2 cups of filtered water to a boil. Remove from heat.
- Add the tea bags and baking soda to the hot water. Steep for 15 minutes. The baking soda neutralizes some of the tannic acid and noticeably reduces bitterness without affecting the flavor.
- Remove the tea bags without squeezing them. Squeezing releases bitter compounds back into the tea.
- Add the sugar and stir until fully dissolved while the tea is still warm.
- Let the tea cool naturally to room temperature, then add the remaining 6 cups of cold water and the lemon juice.
- Transfer to a 2 quart pitcher with a lid and refrigerate until cold.
Fresh-squeezed lemonade with less sugar than standard recipes. Tart, refreshing, and costs almost nothing per batch. Makes 2 quarts.
Ingredients
- 6 lemons
- 1/3 cup sugar
- Enough cold filtered water to make 2 quarts (about 6 to 7 cups depending on lemon yield)
Directions
- Squeeze the juice from all 6 lemons. Remove seeds but leave the pulp in using a spoon. The pulp adds body and a little extra flavor.
- Pour the juice into a pitcher and add enough cold water to fill it about halfway.
- Add the sugar and stir until fully dissolved. I use a metal spoon for stirring since wood can sometimes absorb and release flavors over time. If you are using a glass pitcher, mix the sugar and juice first in a metal pot before adding water, to avoid the thermal shock of stirring vigorously in a cold glass container.
- Add the remaining cold water to fill the pitcher. Stir once more, then refrigerate until cold before serving.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is diet soda actually a better option than regular soda?
Based on the research I have read, probably not by as much as most people assume. Some studies suggest that artificially sweetened drinks can still trigger insulin responses and cravings similar to regular sugary drinks. They also do not address the habit of reaching for a sweet drink as a default. Replacing soda with something you make yourself gives you more control over what is actually in it, which is the more meaningful change regardless of what sweetener you are trying to avoid.
Why does the iced tea recipe use baking soda?
Baking soda is slightly alkaline and neutralizes some of the acidic compounds in steeped black tea that cause bitterness. A small amount, about 1/8 teaspoon per 2 quart batch, makes the tea noticeably smoother without any detectable baking soda flavor. It is a simple trick that lets you steep longer for stronger flavor without the bitterness penalty.
Can I make the iced tea without sugar at all?
Yes. Unsweetened iced tea is perfectly good, especially if you are using good quality tea and not over-steeping it. The baking soda trick helps a lot here since bitterness is the main complaint with unsweetened tea. If you find it too flat without any sweetener, a small amount of lemon juice adds brightness without sugar.
What kind of coffee brewer do you recommend for cutting sugar from coffee?
I use a Clever Coffee Dripper, which is an immersion brewer that produces a clean, full-bodied cup without bitterness. It is simple to use, easy to clean, and inexpensive compared to most specialty brewing equipment. Pairing it with freshly ground whole beans makes a bigger difference than most people expect. My longer writeup on making better coffee at home is in the brew your own coffee post if you want the full breakdown.
What do you drink during long workouts or hikes?
For longer outdoor efforts in the heat I use my homemade orange matcha sports drink, which adds sodium and carbohydrates to replace what you lose through heavy sweating. Plain water is not enough for efforts over an hour in hot weather and the homemade version costs almost nothing per serving compared to commercial sports drinks.
Comments